MONROVIA – The Civil Society Network of Liberia (CSNL) has criticized the recent ruling by Criminal Court ‘C’ Judge Joe S. Barkon, in the case of Marie Nellon vs. Johnny Momoh. CSNL described the decision as unjust and a serious blow to public trust in Liberia’s justice system.
In a statement issued Thursday, CSNL, a coalition of civil society organizations, dedicated to promoting justice and accountability, expressed disappointment in the court’s decision to dismiss criminal charges of Theft of Property and Burglary filed against Cllr. Johnny Momoh, a prominent lawyer, was represented by Madam Marie Nellon.
Civil Society Network of Liberia contends that Judge Barkon’s reliance on Chapter 3, Section 3.2 of the Criminal Procedure Law of Liberia to throw out the case was legally unfounded and procedurally inappropriate.
The group argued that the section cited was inapplicable given that the charges in the March 27, 2024, writ and indictment differed significantly from the April 8, 2023, writ, which had been withdrawn with prejudice through a nolle prosequi.
“The ruling by Judge Barkon not only ignores the fundamental principles of justice but also endangers the very fabric of human rights protections in Liberia,” the CSNL statement read.
“It is deeply troubling that a Liberian woman who has endured physical and psychological torment would be denied her right to justice.”
According to CSNL, Madam Nellon suffered severe abuse at the hands of Mr. Momoh, who allegedly expelled her from their shared residence and disposed of personal belongings, including jewelries and cash, valued at over US$575,000. Despite what CSNL described as “overwhelming evidence,” the court dismissed the charges on procedural grounds.
“This is a clear miscarriage of justice,” CSNL emphasized.
“The Judiciary of Liberia has a constitutional obligation to deliver justice impartially and uphold the rights of all individuals, especially women who are often vulnerable to abuse.”
The organization further questioned whether Mr. Momoh’s status as a legal professional may have influenced the outcome of the case. “No one is above the law, and no one should be shielded from accountability because of their affiliation with the legal community,” CSNL said.
CSNL welcomed Madam Nellon’s decision to appeal the ruling to the Supreme Court and vowed to continue advocating on her behalf.
“We will stand by Madam Nellon as she seeks justice at the highest court. Her case is a test of our country’s commitment to the rule of law and human dignity,” the group concluded.
The Supreme Court is expected to hear the appeal in its next judicial term. Legal analysts say the outcome could set a precedent on the limits of procedural dismissals in criminal cases involving withdrawn charges and new indictments.
