By Moses Zangar, Jr
The decision not to arrest Deputy Minister J. Bryant McGill amid allegations of sexually assaulting a 14-year-old girl has sparked widespread concern about the integrity of Liberia’s justice system. While Deputy Minister J. Bryant McGill is reportedly cooperating with authorities, his continued freedom raises serious concerns about the integrity of the investigation. As a high-ranking official, McGill has access to resources and networks that could potentially be used to tamper with evidence, intimidate witnesses, or obstruct justice. Arresting him would not only mitigate these risks but also ensure that the investigation proceeds without undue interference, reinforcing public trust in the justice system and demonstrating the government’s commitment to accountability. Here’s why I think Deputy Minister J. Bryant McGill should be arrested immediately and put behind bars:
1. Legal Accountability and Equal Application of the Law
Inspector General Gregory Coleman’s assertion that “no one is above the law” must be upheld in practice, not just in rhetoric. The delay in arresting McGill risks undermining public confidence in the justice system. While careful legal procedures are essential, the principle of equal application of the law demands that allegations of this gravity – especially involving a minor – be treated with urgency. Arresting McGill would not preclude further investigation but would demonstrate that his position does not shield him from accountability.
2. Precedent and Public Perception
Failing to arrest McGill sets a dangerous precedent that high-ranking officials can evade immediate consequences for alleged crimes. This perception erodes trust in the government’s commitment to its stated zero-tolerance policy on sexual and gender-based violence. Public patience, as urged by the IGP, is difficult to maintain when the accused remains free, potentially influencing witnesses or evidence. Arresting McGill would signal that the government prioritizes justice over political considerations.
3. Risk of Evidence Tampering
While McGill is reportedly cooperating with authorities, his freedom poses risks to the integrity of the investigation. As a Deputy Minister, he has access to resources and networks that could be used to tamper with evidence, intimidate witnesses, or obstruct justice. Arresting him would mitigate these risks and ensure the investigation proceeds without undue interference.
- Victim-Centered Justice
The victim, a 14-year-old girl, is under the care of the Ministry of Gender and Social Protection, receiving psychosocial support. However, the delay in arresting the accused sends a message that her allegations are not being treated with the urgency they deserve. This could discourage other victims of sexual violence from coming forward, fearing that their cases will not be prioritized. Arresting McGill would affirm the government’s commitment to protecting vulnerable individuals and pursuing justice for victims.
- International Standards and Commitments
Liberia has ratified international conventions on the rights of children and the elimination of violence against women, including the Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC) and the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW). These commitments obligate the government to act decisively in cases of sexual violence, particularly against minors. Delaying McGill’s arrest risks violating these obligations and damaging Liberia’s international reputation.
- Suspension Alone Is Insufficient
While President Boakai’s decision to suspend McGill is a step in the right direction, it does not address the core issue of accountability. Suspension is an administrative measure, not a legal one. Arresting McGill would demonstrate that the government is taking concrete legal action, rather than relying solely on symbolic gestures.
- Probable Cause Already Established
The IGP’s statement suggests that investigators are still gathering evidence to establish probable cause. However, the allegations, combined with the ongoing cooperation of McGill and the victim’s testimony, likely meet the threshold for probable cause under Liberian law. Arresting McGill would not preclude further evidence collection but would ensure that the legal process is initiated promptly.
Conclusion
The decision not to arrest Deputy Minister McGill amid allegations of sexual assault against a minor raises serious concerns about legal accountability, public trust, and victim protection. While thorough investigations are necessary, the gravity of the allegations and the risks posed by McGill’s continued freedom warrant immediate legal action. Arresting McGill would uphold the principle of equal application of the law, protect the integrity of the investigation, and affirm the government’s commitment to justice and international standards.
About the Author
Moses Zangar, Jr. is a seasoned Liberian journalist and Communication for Development (C4D) expert with extensive experience in the mainstream media and international organizations, including the United Nations. He is passionate about governance reforms, transparency, and creating opportunities for Liberia’s youth.
